Dissent, Injustice, and the Meanings of America by Steven H. Shiffrin

By Steven H. Shiffrin

The writer argues that american citizens could be in a position to dissent within the identify of unfastened speech, yet are limited via the country's significant associations, together with the best courtroom and the mass media. The ebook refers back to the implications of dissent in regards to issues like cigarette ads, racist speech and flag burning, including that such an procedure unearths weaknesses within the ways to unfastened speech taken through postmodernism, Republicanism, deliberative democratic idea, outsider jurisprudence, and liberal thought. Social capabilities of dissent are emphasised during the textual content, in recognize of scuffling with injustice and its position in cultural struggles over the meanings of the United States. the writer contends that defamation legislation could be much less protecting of these in energy, advertisement pursuits within the media might be loosened and children should be taught the significance of tough injustice.

Show description

Read or Download Dissent, Injustice, and the Meanings of America PDF

Best political history books

Jazz, Rock, and Rebels: Cold War Politics and American Culture in a Divided Germany

Within the twenty years after international struggle II, Germans on either side of the iron curtain fought vehemently over American cultural imports. Uta G. Poiger lines how westerns, denims, jazz, rock 'n' roll, and stars like Marlon Brando or Elvis Presley reached young people in either Germanies, who eagerly followed the hot types.

The Quality of Freedom

In his provocative new ebook, Matthew Kramer bargains a scientific concept of freedom that demanding situations many of the different significant modern remedies of the subject.

Issues and Methods in Comparative Politics: An Introduction

Development at the strengths of the second one variation, this very hot textbook keeps to supply the simplest creation to the recommendations of comparative study in political technological know-how. Divided into 3 elements, the booklet starts off through interpreting diverse equipment, using those easy methods to dominant matters in comparative politics utilizing a wealth of topical examples from all over the world, after which discusses the hot demanding situations within the region.

British Military Withdrawal and the Rise of Regional Cooperation in South-East Asia, 1964–73

This ebook examines the hyperlinks among Britain's withdrawal from its east of Suez function and the institution of South-East Asian nearby safeguard preparations. The hyperlink among those occasions isn't direct, yet a dating existed, that's very important to a much broader knowing of the improvement of local protection preparations.

Additional info for Dissent, Injustice, and the Meanings of America

Example text

Flag burning is seen as an important component of democratic dialogue because it, and other acts of dissent like it, call attention to the failure of the country to live up to its ideals. The Bill of Rights progressives seek to encourage and protect the Emersonian dissenter,58 and flag burners squarely fit that model. But the dissent model is not premised exclusively on notions that individuals thrive when they feel free to speak out. It is not just a self-expression model. The dissent model assumes that in large-scale societies powerful interest groups and self-seeking politicians and bureaucrats are unavoidable.

53 The flag amendment was uniquely threatening to progressives because it struck a symbolic dagger at the notion that the First Amendment is an important reflection of our “profound national commitment” to protect dissent. No doubt, the symbolic effect of a flag-burning statute upheld by the Supreme Court would be disheartening, but the relative rhetorical and constituting power of statutes, decisions, and the Constitution are not the same. The scriptural Constitution is a more important cultural symbol, and it constitutes us in ways that statutes upheld by the Supreme Court do not.

The connection of liberals (and many radicals) to the country is not just a Hobbesian bargain; it is a form of nationalism,89 a matter of cultural and political identity. It may be thought that this is a benign form of nationalism, and to a large extent it is. 90 Nonetheless, the liberal position on free speech rights has political costs. Some of the subtle political costs are intrinsically bound up with the flag-burning controversy or the controversy over funding of the arts. In order to uphold their position, liberals91 have championed the view that this country values and prizes dissent, freedom, liberty, the marketplace of ideas, democratic dialogue, and/or controversy.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.31 of 5 – based on 29 votes